Hi Danny,
See below for my investigation.
On Mon, 12 Nov 2012 23:02:19 -0000
"dannyjones183" <dannyjones183_at_yahoo.com> wrote:
> Hello Shlomi,
>
> Part II:
>
> While reconstructing your solution, I ran into an anomaly. The first 73
> moves work in FcPro, but move 74 can't occur.
>
> #00006240 Attempt: 1 NumFcs=4 (ShlomiFish) 175 moves
> 4a 4b 1c 14 45 8d 83 2h 63 a8
> 54 13 6a c6 45 61 85 58 54 6c
> 61 84 a6 8a 1h d8 68 6d 45 b6
> 2b 26 42 64 24 26 d2 27 46 56
> 87 8d c8 18 12 1c 17 54 82 51
> b5 64 8b d8 78 75 85 8d b8 7b
> 78 7h 71 b7 46 81 d8 58 48 43
> 57 5b 5d
> 2h 6h 6h 2h 2h 6h 6h
>
> The closest I can come to your moves after "5d" is "6h 2h 6h 2h 6h".
> This then allows your next move of "56".
>
Well, the problem is that the 2h is counted explicitly in the solution in
FC-Pro format emitted by fc-solve, but done implicitly by FC-Pro. The moves in
question are:
Move a card from stack 5 to the foundations
Foundations: H-4 C-3 D-3 S-0
Freecells: 3S QH JH KC
: 8S 7D 6S 5H 4S
: QS 7H 6C 5D 4C
: 9C AS JS 8H 8C KH KD QC JD TC 9D
: 9H
: TS 2S
: 7C 6D 5C 4D
: KS QD JC TH
: TD 9S 8D 7S 6H 5S
====================
Move a card from stack 1 to the foundations
Foundations: H-4 C-4 D-3 S-0
Freecells: 3S QH JH KC
: 8S 7D 6S 5H 4S
: QS 7H 6C 5D
: 9C AS JS 8H 8C KH KD QC JD TC 9D
: 9H
: TS 2S
: 7C 6D 5C 4D
: KS QD JC TH
: TD 9S 8D 7S 6H 5S
====================
Move a card from stack 5 to the foundations
Foundations: H-4 C-4 D-4 S-0
Freecells: 3S QH JH KC
: 8S 7D 6S 5H 4S
: QS 7H 6C 5D
: 9C AS JS 8H 8C KH KD QC JD TC 9D
: 9H
: TS 2S
: 7C 6D 5C
: KS QD JC TH
: TD 9S 8D 7S 6H 5S
The "Move a card from stack 1 to the foundations" (stack 1 is stack 2 in
the "standard notation", as the indexes are 0-based), should not be done
implicitly, because the rank of the "S" foundations" is lower than that of C by
3, so it seems like an FC-Pro bug.
Regards,
Shlomi Fish
> Regards, Danny
>
>
> --- In fc-solve-discuss_at_yahoogroups.com, Shlomi Fish <shlomif_at_...>
> wrote:
> >
> > The number of the deal of 175 moves was 6,240 and its solution was:
> >
> > [[Num Iters]]=197926
> > [[Num FCS Moves]]=206
> > [[Num FCPro Moves]]=175
> > [[Start]]
> > 4a 4b 1c 14 45 8d 83 2h 63 a8
> > 54 13 6a c6 45 61 85 58 54 6c
> > 61 84 a6 8a 1h d8 68 6d 45 b6
> > 2b 26 42 64 24 26 d2 27 46 56
> > 87 8d c8 18 12 1c 17 54 82 51
> > b5 64 8b d8 78 75 85 8d b8 7b
> > 78 7h 71 b7 46 81 d8 58 48 43
> > 57 5b 5d 2h 6h 6h 2h 2h 6h 6h
> > 56 45 c4 34 6c 16 1h 12 1h 15
> > 43 d1 b1 53 8d 8h 71 54 a5 17
> > 1b 1a d1 23 2d b2 1b d1 72 6d
> > a6 27 26 c2 34 6a 6c a6 2a c2
> > 8c 8h 3h 87 8h c8 31 5c 62 b5
> > a6 13 72 7b 31 8a b7 c8 13 1b
> > 27 a1 5c 72 d5 6a 43 b6 5d 46
> > c5 36 d4 1b 3c 3h 7h 27 b1 4d
> > 72 3b 3h c4 1c 31 3h c3 4c b1
> > 6b 6h c4 32 3c
> > [[End]]
> > Reached Board No. 6240 at 1352570506.213502 (total_num_iters=2367638)
> >
> > =====
>
>
--
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Shlomi Fish http://www.shlomifish.org/
List of Text Processing Tools - http://shlom.in/text-proc
*shlomif:* hack, hack, hack ; save ; make ; make test; commit. And start over.
*mrjink:* hack, hack, hack; save; make; swear; fix typos; save; make; make
test; swear some more; hack some more; save; make; make test; cheer; commit.
*meep:* hack, make, test, segfault, oh noes, revert to previous revision
Please reply to list if it's a mailing list post - http://shlom.in/reply .
Received on Fri Nov 16 2012 - 03:49:21 IST